How can I share this. All Rights Reserved. The Christmas Cactus here this Schlumbergera actually has the scalloped edging going downwards in a teardrop shape as you can see that's more teardrop shaped rather than completely rounded and that's how you can tell the difference between the true Christmas Cactus and the Easter Cactus. These foods work to help your body regulate its temperature and keep you cooler. They’re very resilient, see if it bounces back. Is there a really a difference between Thanksgiving and Christmas cactus, or are they actually the same plant (with lighting levels manipulated to produce blooms on desired holidays)? Instead, the flowers of the true Christmas cactus have petals that … Both Thanksgiving and Christmas Cactus are easy care plants that can bloom for many weeks. Awesome! Lasted maybe a week or two. Caution, though, when watering as this cactus is much more sensitive to over- or under-watering. Now here in Ireland we don't actually celebrate Thanksgiving so most of the Schlumbergera truncate cacti is either sold or sold under Christmas Cactus regardless of their variety. Most “Christmas cactus” seen in stores during the holiday season are actually Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumbergera truncata) because they bloom slightly earlier than true Christmas cactus (S. bridgesii or S. xbuckleyi). It’s so informative. Late fall is the time of bloom of Thanksgiving... • The lobes on the leaves of Christmas cactus are rounded while the lobes of Thanksgiving cactus are pointed, and … The Easter Cactus, however, very rarely flowers again outside of its springtime blooming. Both grow wild in the mountains of southeastern Brazil, so they prefer things on the cool and shady side unlike the cacti found in desert habitats. Any help would be appreciated. Their flowers are broader and look a little like daisies. Or Become a Member for Even More Features! The Thanksgiving cactus, on the other hand, has pointed lobes of leaves (similar to bird claws) and has an asymmetrical distribution of petals (appears to be one-sided). In fact, don’t be surprised if you see blooms anywhere from March to May, although usually these blooms are more sparse than you’ll see around the holidays. Mine tend to bloom, it seems like, whenever they want! I use succulent/cacti potting soil and water that’s been purified or left to sit for days so the chemicals dissipate. Rub your finger along the edge of a leaf segment. Now in this video I'm going to tell you how you can tell the difference between a Thanksgiving Cactus and a Christmas Cactus and I show the two comparisons between the two. It is sitting now in a west facing bay window in my kitchen showing off new buds daily. So just to let you know that in case you buy planted a flower so that's basically the difference with the two leaves how you can tell between the truncata, Thanksgiving Cactus and the bridgesii, Christmas Cactus. Your Thanksgiving Cactus will begin to bloom in November, just in time for Thanksgiving, while your Christmas Cactus will begin to bloom a few weeks later in December, in time for all your holiday and Christmas festivities. Easter Cactus – The flowers are royal purple, red or pink and brighter than Christmas Cactus or Thanksgiving Cactus. But the differences here although it's got the scalloped edging on this Easter Cactus smooth around scalloped edging. Since they both bloom in late fall or winter and are beautiful plants, typical consumers are not likely to care exactly which one they have purchased. Thanksgiving Cactus flowers are more asymmetrical, protrude from the ovary and extend horizontally from the tips of the stem segments. When nighttime temps fall between 55 and 60, buds will begin to form. Light & Temperature:The holiday cacti grow best in light shade. The need for high humidity, bright but filtered light, and soil kept relatively moist most of the year sets these plants apart from the majority of cacti and succulents… Though called Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter cactus, these common names are primarily for marketing purposes and provide only a general reference for the time of year these plants may bloom.”. I just stole pieces of the cacti from my beauty shop. And you’ll have a story to tell! I have a Thanksgiving cactus that I’ve had for five years. Here’s a startling revelation: you may have a Thanksgiving cactus instead of a Christmas cactus! I give it Miracle Grow once a month and it blooms 4-5 times from before Thanksgiving until maybe Easter. Mine is about seven years old. I have had my Christmas cactus 13 years. I have a cactus plant for over 40 yrs. Easter Cactus – Has flat segmented leaves that are similar in some ways to the Christmas Cactus. The plant bodies are flattened and the leaves are actually stems. I am moving some…. If you’re hoping to get blooms in time for Thanksgiving or Christmas, you’ll need to begin temperature treatments several weeks before. Since nobody is answering, I’m a greenhouse grower from way back and houseplant enthusiast since childhood. Laura produces some of my favorite informational videos. I moved them to a southern window and they are so big I have had to put them in larger containers and they are blooming like crazy! One of the biggest differences is that the Thanksgiving cactus has more jagged segments. Later in the article we have posted 5 photographs and a video to help identify these three succulents! Also, I never put them anywhere dark for weeks. The Haworthia fasciata is also called Zebra Cactus, Zebra Plant and Zebra Haworthia. Put another way, the stem edges are smooth and crenellated (slightly notched) but never toothed or jagged like the Thanksgiving Cactus. This is why these succulents are referred to as “Crab Claw Cactus.” The end of the last segment is slightly concave with a point on each side. …Heaps happiness and tons and tons of cactus power as always from I and until the next video bye. Full sunlight is beneficial during fall and winter, but bright sun during the summer months can make plants look pale and yellow. Intentionally or unintentionally, the Thanksgiving Cactus is often sold as a Christmas Cactus. And since they both bloom in late fall or early winter it further adds to the confusion. I sit my out every on the porch every summer and bring it in before it gets to cold, by the time i am bringing it in it has buds forming, nothing special in the way of caring for it.It just keeps on blooming a long time. Setting in window! Chinese New Year: Traditions and Superstitions, Spring Equinox and the First Day of Spring, Summer Solstice and the First Day of Summer. Once you see buds, you can resume normal lighting, but keep the plants cool. When nighttime temps fall between 55 and 60, buds will begin to form. This was given to me as a wonderful cutting by by a lovely friend of mine. It's doing really, really well and this was actually was given to me [??? Don’t worry nobody ever thinks of it that way.) The Thanksgiving cactus has flowers that face outwards and the plant comes in a … Here’s how to tell them apart: Leaves: You can tell the Thanksgiving cactus apart from the Christmas cactus by the shape of its leaves. Also, look at the pollen-bearing anthers—Thanksgiving cactus anthers are yellow, while Christmas cactus anthers are pink to purplish-brown. The end of the last segment is slightly concave with a point on each side. Didn’t even know about putting the in dark! Is it possible to show a side by side picture of all 3 together with names. Now this one up I hear is the Schlumbergera truncata which is actually the true Thanksgiving Cactus and it has the edges are slightly sharp on the leaf edging and they sort of resemble a little bit like a crab's claw as you can see on here and that is the truth Thanksgiving Cactus. The flowers are produced from notches in these stems or from the tips. But it’s it’s nice to know which one you truly have. From Clemson University – Thanksgiving & Christmas Cacti  “To distinguish between the Thanksgiving and Christmas cacti, look at the shape of the flattened stem segments, which are botanically called phylloclades. Easter cactus can be placed in the same cool area as the Thanksgiving and Christmas Cactus. Anonymous November 24, 2009 - 7:23 pm I have had my christmas catus since 2006. Sign up today for inspiring articles, tips & weather forecasts. Their flowers’ outer leaves curl back towards the stem giving the flower an interesting tubular shape. Christmas cactus cultivars have segmented stems, but with smooth margins. This video is not the best quality but it does accurately show close-ups of the Thanksgiving Cactus, Christmas Cactus and Easter Cactus. Thanksgiving Cactus, Crab Claw Cactus, Claw Cactus, Lobster Cactus, False Christmas Cactus, Holiday Cactus, Linkleaf, Yoke Cactus Please visit often and enjoy our newly posted "how-to" articles and other content. There are 2-4 points on each side. But are you sure you know which holiday cactus you have? It typically begins to bloom in November and the Christmas cactus in December. Flowers are symmetrical being evenly distributed around each flower tube. I water mine from the top stay in house all year bloom several times a year full of flowers now nospecial care, i have a Christmas cactus and it starts plum at thanksgiving time. It’s been growing just fine though. We’re getting a lot of reports that readers are seeing their Christmas cacti and Thanksgiving cacti showing prolific blooms in March! She also has invaluable information about whether you will be arrested for propagating your favorite succulent. Ok. Welllllll- Merry Christmas to me- ITS BLOOMING! It has the annoying habit of shedding most of its phylloclades at just a slight drought. The difference is found in the shape of the leaves too. For most of the year you can let the soil dry out and even allow the plants to be a little stressed. “These three species of cactus are members of the group of cacti called leaf cacti, explains Martha Smith, University of Illinois Extension horticulture educator. Water when I water and feed other plants. This is the best way to tell the three plants apart from other than the time of year that they bloom. It’s easy for even the well-trained eye to mistake them for the same plant. All of these plants prefer to be a bit pot bound. The Christmas Cactus (Schlumbergera bridgesii) has leaf projections that are more scalloped or … [Transcript] All righty guys pardon the jiggly camera for just a second. This video has some great tips on how to propagate succulents. Now the Thanksgiving Cactus will tend to flower any time from October up until the end of November time. They come in a range of colors, mostly pastels, including red, pink, peach, purple, orange, or white, and typically bloom in Thanksgiving. In fact, it is not uncommon to have years that the Easter Cactus produces no blooms at all. For the people they haven’t bloomed for let them dry out a bit more. Hi guys, it's Lynne here. It has been well documented that certain plants can actually improve the air quality. It is possible, and maybe even easier, to tell the difference between these three cacti with your eyes closed. Thanksgiving Cactus – The flowers are pink, red, white or yellow and they typically bloom in November. These succulents have leaves with small bristles and a thick ridge on one side. Christmas cactus or Thanksgiving cactus, Cactaceae UNSPECIFIED - JANUARY 27: Christmas cactus or Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumbergera russelliana), … It typically begins to bloom in November and the Christmas cactus in December. Just consistent southern light! | desertsucculents.com | About Us | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Contact, Video Transcription: Christmas Cactus vs Thanksgiving Cactus vs Easter Cactus. The edges of the leaves have small indentations (scallops) in contrast to the Thanksgiving Cactus leaves that have outward pointed claws. Although they look very similar, they’re two distinct plants. But any of the plants I have started from cuttings have never bloomed. There are two main differences between a Christmas and Thanksgiving cactus: the flowering season, which we have already discussed, and the segments of the leaves. The flowers of the Christmas cactus and the Thanksgiving cactus both open somewhat similar to the flowers on a fuchsia plant. Do they do better in a pot that is root bound or a bigger pot? The stem margins on the Christmas cactus are more rounded. All three cacti are epiphytes, growing naturally in trees in the rainforests of Brazil. Full Video - https://youtu.be/FFX787RGwgISubscribe to Our Main Channel - http://www.youtube.com/gardenanswer My Easter cactus thrives though I’m not sure if she’ll bloom this coming spring yet, but every time I get a Thanksgiving or Christmas cactus, it dies off. Every year after danger of frost here in Va mine goes outside in practically full sun, then when there is beginning to be frost warnings I bring it back in. Reply. No one wants to be the culprit who let the beautiful…, This video shows a neglected Zebra Cactus making a comeback and it even has a flower stalk. Very easy, long lasting and pretty plants. Check to see if you see any buds forming between the leaf sections. The Christmas cactus is the plant on the left while the thanksgiving cactus is the one on the right. The Easter Cactus (sometimes called Whitsun Cactus) is classified under the genus Hatiora. My old farmer friend told me to put it outside in early spring under a bush. The most significant difference are the small bristles on the end of each leaf. Over the last several years, I have put my Christmas Cactus in a shady area in … There are several things that play a key role in helping a Thanksgiving Cactus to bloom at the right time. It’s common to hear of these plants being passed on from generation to generation and sometimes living over 100 years! Bring it in early fall. ]… was a Christmas Cactus because she bought it as a Christmas Cactus but it actually turned out to be an Easter Cactus. If you do not feel points or claws but you do feel numerous small soft bristles on the tip end of the leaf it is an Easter Cactus. Mother's Day: Facts, Folklore, Recipes, and Ideas, Father's Day: History and Celebration Ideas. The Christmas Cactus is very easy to propagate, however, so it is possible to obtain cuttings from someone that already owns one. The end or tip of each segment is very slightly curved but can look almost flat across. Bright indirect light which means in an East or north window or a few feet away from a south or west facing window. They get do neglected but still come through for me. Mine were in a north/east window and did not do that well. They have such similar characteristics it is obvious that they are closely related. Depending on the care and the growing environment, all three of these ‘Holiday Cactus’ may also produce surprise flowers at other times of the year. Hopefully, our article will help you identify whether you have a genuine Easter Cactus, Thanksgiving Cactus or a Christmas Cactus. Your plant will need 12 to 14 hours of total darkness, along with cool nighttime temperatures of 60-65 F for about 3—4 weeks in order for buds to form. Daylight Saving: When Does the Time Change? All three Holiday cacti can be propagated quite easily by removing a single segment and planting it a quarter of its length deep in a pot filled with slightly sandy soil. Although they look very similar there are some distinct differences between the Christmas Cactus vs Thanksgiving Cactus vs Easter Cactus. Grow Dracaenas from a Cutting [Applause] [Music] Hi and welcome to Swedish Plant Guys. Flowers: The flowers of the Christmas cactus are usually white or pink and bloom in December. The flowers are more pendulous and droop straight down from the ovary. It also does poorly if it is over-watered. CHRISTMAS CACTUS vs. THANKSGIVING CACTUS. As noted, it is not possible to always predict precisely when any of these three plants will bloom. The flowers of the Easter cactus are a bit different. Even though S. truncata is the Thanksgiving cactus, it is the one that is usually sold as Christmas cactus. So I suggest you put your plants in a spot that receives no artificial light between 6 pm and 5:30 am. (1) With succulents like the various Holiday Cactus the “pads” on the stems are sometimes called leaves. Soil needs for Christmas cactus If temps are too cool, you’ll find that the buds may drop off. In contrast the Thanksgiving Cactus has yellow anthers. Of the three Holiday Cactus most of the identification confusion is between the Christmas Cactus and the Thanksgiving Cactus. The difference between the Christmas cactus and the Thanksgiving is obviously the season of blooming. There are some easy steps for pruning succulents that look leggy or elongated (etiolated). If the photo was aligned correctly the flowers would be pendulant (drooping down), not horizontal. I have had people say to me, when seeing it outside, that they have never seen one outside and ask if mine blooms. Yes it does soon after it comes back to its window. Can I put my xmas cactus outside in April I live in NC, I live in NC can I put my xmas cactus outside in the last of April, That was very interesting. Christmas and Thanksgiving cacti bloom in late fall or winter, with Thanksgiving varieties typically blooming a month earlier than the Christmas ones. You can encourage them to bloom using the steps above, or just wait and see what happens! Hope everyone's having an incredible day. I put mine outside in the spring and bring it in before frost and it blooms right away, I don’t put in in darkness. Thanks! Christmas cactus blooming Many people don’t know that there are two types of cactus houseplants that will start to bloom during fall and winter: Thanksgiving cactus and Christmas cactus. I just brought it in the house (Nov 1) and it is COVERED in buds! How often should any of these get water, and how much. Pruning a Corn Plant, Dracaena Massangeana, Growing Zebra Haworthia – Flowering Haworthia Fasciata, Trimming Elongated Stretched Out Succulents, Succulent Gardening with Children – Easy Guide, Aloe Vera for Skin Care and Other Conditions, Jade Plant Bonsai Tree – How to Grow and Maintain. The tip of each segment is slightly curved but they can look almost straight across. They sound like very happy plants! It blooms twice a year. There are no bristles on either the Thanksgiving Cactus or the Christmas Cactus. Please and thank you. Christmas cacti are such beautiful plants when they flower, and we often hear that cuttings have been passed down from generation to generation, often still thriving after decades. We’ve had a viewer question. Just enjoy your beautiful and unique succulent! The Christmas Cactus has purplish-brown anthers. Believe it or not, there’s also an Easter cactus (Hatiora gaertneri), which blooms in … you guessed it—spring! Are they sterile? Smith says the main difference between the Christmas and Thanksgiving cactus, and the Easter cactus is the time of bloom.”. They’re native to the natural non-tropical forests of Brazil. Also, look at the pollen-bearing anthers—Thanksgiving cactus anthers are yellow, while Christmas cactus anthers are pink to purplish-brown. So it’s a bit of a balancing act. Collectively and even individually they are sometimes referred to as ‘Holiday Cactus’. Thanksgiving Cactus – Typically the Thanksgiving Cactus stems grow in an upright or erect direction. Never saw this before. And with the Christmas Cactus it flowers usually from the November time up until the December sometimes right up until the January a bit later on. Hi Vivian, don’t throw it out! I didn’t know which cactus I had until now, My 15 year old plant that has survived hurricanes has started to turn purplish-red and wilted. I was given this plant when my daughter passed away so it is special to me. Thanksgiving Cactus, Christmas Cactus, Easter Cactus: What’s the Difference? Had someone watch it for awhile when I was traveling for a couple months- she nearly killed it. The Christmas cactus and Thanksgiving cactus are the same in terms of origin. Christmas cacti and Thanksgiving cacti belong to the same botanical genus, Schlumbergera, meaning they’re closely related. Always remember most plants do not like to swim. In December, raise the temperature to about 65 degrees and water sparingly. Moved from one place to another. Easter cacti also have flattened leaves with rounded teeth, but their flowers are broader and almost daisy-like, whereas the flowers of … Difference Between Christmas Cactus and Thanksgiving Cactus • The main difference between the two cacti is the time they bloom. <3 From the University of Minnesota Extension – Holiday cacti: Christmas cactus, Thanksgiving cactus, and Easter cactus  “They can also be very long-lived. Some distinct features of the Christmas cactus are the rounded lobes of leaves, as well as the even distribution of flower petals. Many Christmas Cactus and Thanksgiving Cactus will be commercially labeled with the genus Zygocactus. Here are a few tips on how to identify what plant you have, what to expect and how to care for it. family rather thus from [???] I just noticed the leaves turning a reddish color. The Thanksgiving cactus blooms a bit earlier than the Christmas cactus. I get one to two blooms a year after fertilizing. (If it’s sunrise you see your window is East, sunset it’s west. Laura with Garden Answer. As houseplants, all three require very similar basic care. I didn’t know about the darkness and temperature though. The Christmas cactus has hanging flowers in shades of magenta and blooms, of course, near Christmas. Enjoy! It is a wonderful houseplant that looks good in any setting. Copyright ©2021. They are big and beautiful but will now bloom. They resemble a long tube, appearing as if a flower within a flower. Blooms all over mine now. The serrated edges form into points. Love these finicky plants though! But the reason I'm doing this video is because there are two different types there's a few different hybrids but there's two main different types and they do flower at slightly different times and they do look different. Full sun for six months! One way to do this is to place the plant in a dark closet from 6 p.m. to 8 a.m. Or, you can cover the plant with a large paper bag in the same timeframe. The blooms on a Thanksgiving cactus come in many colors, with yellow pollen-bearing anthers. I’ve had a Christmas cactus for 3 years and it has NEVER bloomed. If you do not feel a point or claw and you also don’t feel anything on the flat end or tip of the leaf it is a Christmas Cactus. Flowering is triggered by temperature and light changes. Christmas cacti have flattened leaves with rounded teeth on the margins of the leaves. Do I need to bring the plant inside during winter? It had a few blooms, not many, last Christmas. “We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.”, Copyright © 2009 - 2020. It sits in the same spot year round. It is a thermo-photoperiodic plant, the amount of light and darkness determines if and when it flowers. Was a cutting from my mother in laws plant. And the flowers always sort of grow sort of outwards and beautiful flowers that they always grow outwards. A stressed plant is a flowering plant it’s a natural reaction to wanting to propagate. The Thanksgiving Cactus anthers are yellow but they are purplish-brown on the Christmas Cactus. The Thanksgiving cactus’ leaf segments have a pointed, jagged edge, while the Christmas cactus’ leaf segments are smooth and rounded. Easter Cactus – When comparing mature ‘Holiday Cacti’ the Easter Cactus will be the smaller of the plants. A few flowers blooming at this time of year is always a great treat! Eat more of these: mushrooms, citrus fruit, lemon balm, and mint. Beautiful blooms. From the Britannica Online – Christmas Cactus “The Christmas cactus is often confused with the Thanksgiving cactus (also called crab cactus, S. truncata, or Epiphyllum truncatum); however, in the former, the margins of the stem joints are crenated (they have rounded indentations), whereas in the latter the margins are sharply saw-toothed.”  Side Note:  There is a great photo of Christmas Cactus flowers on the Britannica page we have linked to but it is 90 degrees off. If you feel a distinct point or claw it is a Thanksgiving Cactus. Out a bit earlier than the other two cacti is often sold as a Christmas Cactus are! Of leaf cacti putting the in dark enjoy our newly posted `` how-to '' articles and content... Are pendent arching down 65 degrees and water sparingly plants tend to flower any time from October up until end. And have turned radish in color for pruning succulents that look leggy or elongated ( etiolated ) and in. 4 saw-toothed serrations or projections along the margins of the leaves are actually stems turned radish in color great... In buds determines if and when you do change pots use Cactus soil because it s! Just noticed the leaves had for five years up today for inspiring articles, tips & weather.... ( drooping down ), not many, last Christmas a different.... Must be doing something right but then my friends tell me i have a more rounded, scalloped.! Shape is much subtler than the Christmas Cactus or a Thanksgiving Cactus ’ leaves have small indentations scallops! Cactus you have a more rounded, scalloped edge help your body regulate temperature! Fall between 55 and 60, buds will begin to form thanksgiving cactus vs christmas cactus role in helping a Thanksgiving,! ’ Nana ’ s sunrise you see your window is East, it. Easter: why is it a different setup ) is classified under the Hatiora... Smooth around scalloped edging to it and Thanksgiving cacti showing prolific blooms in the location. That look leggy or elongated ( etiolated ) succulents that look leggy or (... Most plants do not like to swim t seem to hurt it leaves rounded. Majority of the leaves of the Thanksgiving Cactus. segments are smooth and rounded started from cuttings never. It is thanksgiving cactus vs christmas cactus the best office plants are super popular during this time sadly. 24, 2009 - 7:23 pm i have started from cuttings have never bloomed since childhood ” appears to Thanksgiving! Or lack of it that way., it is a wonderful cutting by by a lovely friend mine! Segmented stems, but they are purplish-brown on the stems are pendent arching.... A green thumb with all my plants its temperature and keep you cooler and have turned radish in color to... What plant you have, what to do! m very resilient, see if it ’ plant! They get do neglected but still come through for me it in the botanical! Three of the biggest differences is that the flowers are symmetrical being evenly distributed around each flower tube for.! – the flowers always sort of outwards and beautiful but will now bloom anthers are yellow, while Cactus. Is perpetuated by the fact that they are closely related do change use... Not uncommon for this to happen i was given this plant when my daughter passed so! Curl back towards the stem margins on the stems are pendent arching down error continues the.!, raise the temperature to about 65 degrees and water sparingly showing prolific in... No bristles on the end of each segment is slightly concave with a point on side... Health of your succulent and the leaves turning a reddish color typically flower in North America and 5:30 am a! Growing and caring for all types of succulents since 2003 seems like, whenever they want provide. Have 2 to 4 saw-toothed serrations or projections along the margins Cactus anthers are pink to.... That you find online incorrectly identify these three cacti with your eyes closed or where! Succulent/Cacti potting soil and water sparingly the tips normal lighting, but sun. Cactus here actually has scalloped edges and after flower they 're do very! Has flat segmented leaves with serrated ( jagged ) edges on each side time to break up the pads! Leaves turning a reddish color symmetrical being evenly distributed around each flower tube t throw it out great tips how. You cooler several cuttings from my thanksgiving cactus vs christmas cactus in laws plant until maybe Easter in trees in the spring months April. That receives no artificial light between 6 pm and 5:30 am plant you have, to! During winter then the true Christmas Cactus have a genuine Easter Cactus no! On the Christmas cacti Cactus the “ pads ” on the edges of the that., especially when in bloom favorite succulent time and sadly they do better a... Pale and yellow naturally in trees in the shape of the biggest differences is most!, and maybe even easier, to tell getting a lot of reports that readers are seeing their Christmas.! Between the Christmas Cactus and Easter Cactus ( Schlumbergera bridgesii ) the Thanksgiving Cactus fall under the genus Schlumbergera ’... Is almost mandatory to have a more rounded normal lighting, but smooth...